Dana, The Gift Economy in Practice — Kazu Haga

What does the gift economy look like when the rent is due? In this second part of his teaching on dana, Kazu Haga moves from principle to practice, with real examples of people living and working by generosity.
Kazu describes a community of about thirty people who pool everything they earn into one collective pot and decide together each quarter how to share it, including the time a friend who lives on very little asked for a piano. He walks through "the money pile," a practice he learned from restorative justice practitioner Dominic Barter, where workshop organizers tear up a flip chart and divide the money openly in front of everyone. He also shares how he works with organizations: instead of quoting a fee, he sends a four-page letter about why the gift matters to him and invites them to decide what they can offer. That approach has actually sustained his family.
In this episode:
• Pooling money and asking for what you actually need
• The money pile: dividing income out in the open
• Working without a fixed fee
• From astrology readings to a plumbing business run on the gift
Kazu closes with an invitation to reflect. When you imagine bringing the gift into your own home, life, work, or organization, what questions come up for you? What are you curious about? What are you excited to try?
This is Part 2 of 2 of Kazu Haga's teaching on the gift economy.

Transcript:

Dana - The Gift Economy in Practice
The Dharma Well · East Bay Meditation Center

------------------------------------------------------------

You're listening to the Dharma Well from East Bay Meditation Center. These teachings are offered in the spirit of dana, made possible by the Friends whose generosity keeps our doors open to everyone. The Gift Economy in Practice. Kazu Haga on Nonviolent Global Liberation, shared money, and asking for what you actually need. I just wanted to share a few more concrete examples. This was one example that I was talking about during the break. But some of you may be familiar with a community slash organization called Nonviolent Global Liberation. This is another organization that is doing some pretty radical practices in the gift economy. Their founder, Miki Kashtan, I believe, has gift economy coaching calls on a regular basis. And one of the things that they do is they have a group of about 30-ish people who make their money either entirely or partially through Nonviolent Global Liberation.

And the way it works is nobody is technically on staff, but all the money that these 30 people make in their lives, whether it's through facilitating workshops for Nonviolent Global Liberation or some other work, it all gets funneled into one collective pot. And then every quarter, everyone who receives money from this pot has a discernment process about what are their needs for the upcoming quarter. and then they make a request and there's a committee made up of about three people who take in all of the requests from all 30 of those people, look at the finances that's available in the collective pot, and then makes decisions about how that pot will get distributed.

I was talking to Miki a while ago and Miki is someone who lives on very, very little. She tries to live really simply and she was telling me, she's like, and I decided that for the next quarter, I'm making a request that I want a piano. I need a piano in my life. I haven't had one to play in many years, and it's a pretty high threshold. I don't think I can continue to exist without a piano. And so as part of her request, she made a request that she receives money to receive a piano. Sometimes when they add up all of the requests, there's not enough money to meet everyone's request. right? So it's really up to those three people to figure out the right distribution. And there's oftentimes emails that goes out to the larger community of Nonviolent Global Liberation saying, hey, we don't have enough money to meet these requests. If anyone can give anything in addition to that, it would really support. And so it's a really radical experiment in the gift economy and in shared economics. There's also a practice that I've done a few times called the money pile, which is a practice that I learned from a restorative justice practitioner in Brazil named Dominic Barter, where the way that we practiced it is I did a—the first time I did it, I did a two-day workshop in Kingian Nonviolence, so unrelated to the gift economy, in Portland, Oregon, and we did it all in a gift economy.

This was before Zoom and before Venmo and all that, so it was a little bit easier to figure out exactly how much money has come in by the end of the workshop. Now, it's like Venmo and PayPal and Square and Stripe and all these things, and so it takes a little while to figure it out. At the end of the two-day workshop, we figured out how much money we raised over those two days, and we put a big flip chart paper and wrote the total number that we raised. Then we did a fishbowl discussion, where in the inner circle were me and my friend Matt, who facilitated the workshop, and then three local people who helped to organize the workshop in Portland. So all the people who contributed to creating that space sat in an inner circle, and then we all went around answering questions like the questions that we asked in the audit, particularly around our personal finances and what our financial needs are right now. And then based on that discussion, one of us would take the flip chart paper and tear a portion of it and say, based on what I just heard from you, like if we had $3,000 or whatever, based on what I heard from you, I think you should receive $1,000." So they would rip a third of the paper and put it in front of that person.

And that person can say, thank you, and I really don't feel like I deserve this much or I need this much, so I'm going to take this $1,000 and rip half of it and then send it your way because I really think you need to be resourced. And we just kept doing this transparently in front of all of the participants until So we landed at an amount that felt good to everybody. We also left an empty chair for any of the participants to jump in at any moment if they wanted to add anything or ask anything. It was this really beautiful practice where one of the young people who helped organize the workshop, I think they ended up getting like $200. It's not a significant amount of money, but they didn't expect to make any money from this workshop. They just really wanted to host this workshop in Portland, so they really did a lot of work, and they were just so touched. I didn't think my labor would be acknowledged in this way. It's not even just about the $200, but it's just that their labor was being appreciated and visibilized in that way.

I hope that as I continue to do this workshop, I can bring that practice back and consider having conversations with folks at EBMC and what would it look like for me and EBMC to have a money pile where we share like all the money that came in and figure out what the right distribution is There's also the you know things like the community gift basket one other thing I want to share and I'm sorry I don't have enough copies. I just have four copies But Emiko if you can share the link at the very bottom of the page that says gift economy for partners This has been a really interesting experiment for me because I try to work in the gift economy. But most of my income comes from contracts from different organizations, communities, churches contract with me to give presentations, workshops, and whatever, and they're always like, so what's your fee? I need to know what your fee is. Instead of just sending them my flat fee, I send them this four page document, and I'm like, I'm sorry, it'd be a lot easier for you if I just gave you a fee, but this is really meaningful to me, so please read this, and then figure out what you can offer.

And the four pages includes a page of why the gift economy matters to me, a page of a condensed version of the principles of the gift economy, a page that includes some transparency about my personal finances, as well as my work, the work that I do in the world so that they can have a sense of what they're giving to, and then a page that includes some questions that I ask each organization, each institution, to ask themselves about how much access do you have and how much do you pay your other contractors that you typically work with? What would it mean for you to support my work? How much do you wanna give? And based on that, just discern for themselves how much they're willing to offer me or they're able to offer me as opposed to just sending them a flat fee.

And I was really nervous at first and I still have questions about how it's going to work long term because, you know, sometimes I work with institutions like universities that have limitless resources. But I do know that since doing this model, it has actually created sustainability for me and my family. And so that's how I work with finances when I work with other institutions and organizations. So I just wanted to give you a sense of how that happens.

There's lots of other small examples of the gift economy in practice. My partner works on the gift economy. She does a lot of one-on-one work and has a page up on their website that just explains a little bit about the gift economy and just ask people to offer what they can. They're not doing it anymore, but they used to also do these things called Freedom Fridays where every Friday they would have a certain number of slots that was entirely free for their services. There's different people that try to incorporate it in different ways. I was sharing during lunch that I have a friend in Ohio who has a plumbing business that runs entirely on the gift economy, which I think is so cool because my partner does astrological readings. It's like astrology, non-violence trainings, meditation, all that kind of makes sense in the gift economy. But like a plumbing business that runs on the gift economy, I think is like so cool. And so there's more and more people who are incorporating this into their work. And so I wanted to give you all some time to think about what it would look like practically speaking for you to bring some of the gift economy into your home, into your life, into your work, into your organization.

And the way this will work is in a few minutes, I'll give you three, four minutes just to do some silent individual journaling or just sitting to see what questions come up for you. When you think about incorporating the gift into your life, what are the questions that come up for you? What are the things that you're curious about? What are the things that you're excited to try?

The Dharma Well is our thank you to Friends of East Bay Meditation Center. If someone in your life would be nourished by these teachings, invite them to become a friend. Monthly giving at any sustainable amount keeps our doors open in Oakland and opens the Dharma Well to them too. You'll find us at eastbaymeditation.org forward slash dharma well.

Comments 0

Post a reply